After the latest weigh-in when Rulon announced that he was leaving the show voluntarily for personal reasons and Kaylee was voted off the ranch, the remaining five contestants meet Tim Gunn who will act as their fairy godfather for makeover week. He promises them three wishes. The first wish is the fairytale makeover, with the end results making each contestant look and feel like a prince or princess. The second wish is sharing their madeover selves with a loved one while being serenaded by OneRepublic. The contestants then return to the reality of the game for their challenge where a key is buried under each of fifty car shaped sandcastles, two of the keys which will start two new Mazda 5's parked a quarter-mile away, the cars which will go to the two people who find the starting keys. At the week's weigh-in, Tim announces the third wish while all those attending the event are moved by a performance from one of their own.